本帖最後由 jc2ssych 於 2021-11-23 11:07 編輯
在戲院睇時亦唔覺有電影感。
落雨夜景好少少。CG色水和contrast麻麻。
有情義結，所以支持下。但比較難評為佳作。
jc2ssych 發表於 2021-11-23 11:05
在戲院睇時亦唔覺有電影感。
落雨夜景好少少。CG色水和contrast麻麻。
有情義結，所以支持下。但比較難評為 ...
我多年前看《十年》時
也有類似的感覺
陳永仁 發表於 2021-11-23 15:15
我多年前看《十年》時
也有類似的感覺
竟然咁比較....
十年係 independent work, 怒火係 blockbuster level。
你係曲線諷刺陳木勝？
jc2ssych 發表於 2021-11-23 17:32
竟然咁比較....
十年係 independent work, 怒火係 blockbuster level。
你係曲線諷刺陳木勝？
怒火同十年都係香港電影
Popcorn也好, independent也好
都是電影
不論片種
只有好看和不好看
Independent也不一定好看
難看的為數不少
我對十年的感覺和你對怒火的感覺似
與我對怒火的評價有何關係呢?
單單是怒火
我已經花了錢入戲院和買碟支持
陳木勝先生的其他作品
三岔口、男兒本色、新警察故事、掃毒、保持通話、危城
我通通都買了碟支持
要曲線諷刺陳大導
我要大費周章?
本帖最後由 jc2ssych 於 2021-11-23 19:24 編輯
陳永仁 發表於 2021-11-23 18:41
怒火同十年都係香港電影
Popcorn也好, independent也好
都是電影
無需激動。
我指出你咁比較無意思，除非你真係有咁意思。我亦用問號作結，意欲瞭解你是否有此意思。咁你話無咪無囉。
我知你有支持，我都有買飛。一，我無 comment 過你對怒火的感覺，你有無睇錯？二，無鬥過買多定買少，亦無追擊你的意圖。三，論壇上有意見可以慢慢講，唔係 confront 你。
完。
jc2ssych 發表於 2021-11-23 19:19
無需激動。
我指出你咁比較無意思，除非你真係有咁意思。我亦用問號作結，意欲瞭解你是否有此意思。咁你 ...
Ridiculous
How come you have the audacity to accuse me of being belligerent while you are the one getting agitated in the first place?
A few minutes ago, you twisted my words into something the complete opposite of what I meant and claimed that I was being sarcastic about Benny Chan. However, after I debunked the accusations you made against me by telling you how supportive of his movies I have long been, you inexplicably come up with a load of nonsense to demonise me.
Make no mistakes about it, I am not confronting you and I never have any intention of confronting you. Right from the start, it's you antagonising me.
陳永仁 發表於 2021-11-24 09:01
Ridiculous
How come you have the audacity to accuse me of being belligerent while you are the one...
{:1_340:} wait for Japanese version
本帖最後由 jc2ssych 於 2021-11-24 17:35 編輯
其實你想討論定鬧人呢？
我只係對呢種比較提出質疑，因為 budget 唔同。然後你就將其上升為指控，粗疏地將電影歸類為「只有好睇和唔好睇」。屌，咁討論區仲討論乜九鳩？
本帖最後由 陳永仁 於 2024-7-25 15:50 編輯
jc2ssych 發表於 2021-11-24 17:33
其實你想討論定鬧人呢？
我只係對呢種比較提出質疑，因為 budget 唔同。然後你就將其上升為指控，粗疏地將 ...
You are just getting increasingly hysterical. Right from the start, you deliberately misconstrue every word I have said about Benny Chan and his movies. And everytime I debunk your absurdity with facts, you just get even more belligerent. This time, you can't even stop yourself from swearing. If you have to express your opinion in a foul language over something so minor, you are the one being uncivilised and running out of things to say. So how come you still reckon you are in any place to condemn me?
Speaking of low budget films, Following(1998), Christopher Nolan's directorial debut, only cost USD6400. In the eyes of so many high-quality moviegoers, it's way better and more intelligent than any of the repetitive MCU garbage. Not because Following(1998) only cost far less than even 1% of the production budget of a MCU movie, it's because Following(1998) is indeed a masterpiece and the MCU simply recycles the same kinda excrement over and over again. Which shows that movies should only be classified as good or bad. People just wanna watch something that can excite them, they certainly don't have the stomach for endless politically correct preaching.
三五成群(1999) is even far more economical than 十年, which completely meets your requirements for being a low budget, independent film. In my opinion, 三五成群 surpasses 十年 in everything on every level. The only reason why the former effortlessly outmatches the latter is that, it's not some kinda liberal propaganda that promotes degeneracy and morbidity, it's 100% based on facts and every cast member in it delivered outstanding performance. Good actors, a good story, and last but not least, good directing and editing, are what it takes to be a good movie. Which doesn't really have much to do with how much money is thrown into it.
Is 十年 a bad movie? To be fair, even I might not have been very gracious about it, I do find three out of five chapters coherent. Lamentably, the other two chapters which promote the racial extermination of my race and suicidal thoughts, really make me lose my appetite.
From my point of view , 十年 is a contradiction. I have never seen a movie this nonsensical, raising concerns about the survival of the local culture whilst promoting the demographic replacement of the indigenous people.
In nationalist movies like, 300 and Braveheart, we don't see the Greeks teaming up with Chinese troopers against the Persians or the Scots getting in line with the Mongolians/ Muslims against the English. We don't even see them complaining that their countries are too homogeneous or condemning themselves for being too racist whilst vowing to fight to the death to thwart a foreign invasion. Even in the face of Armageddon, true patriots don't get themselves bred out of existence with foreigners looking nothing like them , in exchange for not getting conquered by a common descent. Except for the typical, anti-German,WWII movies, that got funded by a tribe that got thrown out of 109 countries, we don't see any race fighting amongst themselves for the total annihilation of their lineage and the deprivation of their essential liberty.
See? I am very eager to talk about movies. I just happen to be much more harmonious
At least, 怒火 has the guts to address the fake-refugee grooming gang problems in Hong Kong.
