Panasonic TH-P46U20H (Plasma) or Toshiba 47ZV650CH (200Hz LCD)?

hifi_friend

I am choosing between Panasonic TH-P46U20H (Plasma) or Toshiba 47ZV650CH (200Hz LCD).  

- 70% TV
- 20% Movie
- 10% Game/used as a computer Monitor

Originally, I think Plasma should be better in picture quality.  However, when I  compared it side by side in the shop, I find that Toshiba 47ZV650C deliver a better picture quality (more detail in black and the picture is clearer).  It is surprise me!  

Not sure if the shop playing trick with the plasma setting.

Do not consider the price, which one do you prefer?  Any comment?

Product information:

Panasonic TH-P46U20H
http://www.panasonic.hk/av/chinese/tv/model/th-p46u20h.aspx

Toshiba 47ZV650CH
http://www.toshiba.com.hk/2010/2009/lineup/zv/specification.html

Thank you very much!

bb132008

如果TV同睇戲多選plasma啦. 立體感好好多!黑位實d.

hifi_friend

Thanks for your reply.  

Yes.  I think so originally.  However, the Toshiba LCD have better picture quality than the Plasma in that shop.  
So, I am asking this question.

I am not sure if the shop setup the plasma badly.

hifi_friend

Any comment? Please.

bb132008

Thanks for your reply.  

Yes.  I think so originally.  However, the Toshiba LCD have better picture ...
hifi_friend 發表於 2011-2-14 17:27

我冇睇過Toshiba LCD ...所以比較唔到.
但我買plasma原因是個人覺得立體d, 睇tv耐d冇咁累...同埋我自己LIKE 睇戲..

到現在用左7個月42V20H, 仍然都係咁正..
等遲D換埋條305 PC 仲正...

hifi_friend

Thanks for your comment

hifi_friend

Any brother has comment?

風仔風仔仔

睇Panasonic Plasma更係去Panasonic 專門店試機啦,
其他無論大型, 小型電器鋪, 唔知係咪Plasma佣金低, 我見過佢地用黃線駁機, 畫面想靚都難啦,
LCD就用HDMI線,
論畫質, 畫面立體感同動態清晰度, LCD仲差少少.
我見過有LCD開左倍頻功能, 畫面會出現爆格情況.唔開又多殘影,
而Plasma本身先天反應時間快, 唔使倍頻功能, 畫面殘影己經唔明顯..
如果俾我一定買Plasma...

paosis

P46U20H係P記最平既MODEL, 而47ZV650CH算係東記上年中階MODEL, 畫質好D唔出奇~

hifi_friend

Yes.  You are correct.  
The price are very similar now and I am choosing between them.  
Hard to choose.  No conclusion yet.