[少量劇透]《葉問3》︰請集中睇打鬥

粗人敵卡 · 發表於 2015-12-24 22:23

如果想睇到更多76師兄嘅分享，快啲登入成為會員啦！

您需要登入收看或下載更多內容。還未成為會員？成為會員

x

睇完今集trailer，小弟依然猶疑好唔好睇今集，因為擔心泰臣一幕會否令今集變成恍如民族自high片，小弟今日睇完，可以話唔係民族自high片，但劇情上比起之前兩集沙石更多。

故事小弟覺得係分了三條線︰保衛小學、與老婆談情和同門對決，連貫性比較上弱，張晉同門對決基本上可以與保衛小學的線連在一起。小弟覺得反而丹爺同熊黛林愛情線係整套電影最可觀的段落，醫院一幕成為《葉問3》最感人的情節。保衛小學的故事線某些情節比較上不合情理…最唔滿意的一幕係於船廠丹爺再次一打十…十一個計埋「為你解悶」譚耀文，大好機會打癱葉問唔去做，令之前鋪排譚耀文心狠手辣形象一下子破壞哂。

張晉之後自立門戶小弟認為編劇想格硬拖硬套戲，好似驚與老婆談情條線做結尾唔夠震撼。其實要安排張晉同丹爺，劇情上可以鋪排譚耀文給錢張晉同丹爺對決，又可以突顯譚耀文戲中歹角形象，又唔會令最後情節睇落好唔連貫。

劇情講完，可以講吓打鬥。群打拍得相當麻麻，船廠群打鏡頭拍得無第二集咁乾淨俐落，丹爺打得比較上慢，可能年紀加上舊患問題，壓軸與張晉對決成為成套電影最精彩一幕，八斬刀對打拍得相當緊張，招式相當華麗，之後唔用武器對決亦打得有板有眼。與泰國拳手打鬥一場亦相當可觀，與樓梯互相對招可以話拍得充滿凶險。泰臣對決…唔算話拍得唔好，但感覺上同第二集同外國拳手打的一樣。

總括而言，今次《葉問3》劇情上係最差一集，打鬥方面水準與之前兩集差唔多，想睇故事的可能較為失望，睇打鬥就會滿足到你。

Nolan · 發表於 2015-12-25 00:35

本帖最後由 Nolan 於 2016-1-30 22:05 編輯

I watched it in the evening. It's a lot better than I expected, the story ain't as riveting as the first one but much better than the second one, at least it's very emotional. Personally, I didn't fancy the second one as there's too many fast-paste action sequences and 黃曉明 doesn't fit the movie at all. But this time, director葉偉信 literally brought the franchise back to life, the fight scenes are very spectacular, there ain't any bloody shaky cameras, almost every actor has a chance to shine aside from 吳千語 and the guy who potrayed the aspiring reporter, we could see more than 95% of the cast perform very well, especially 張晉 and even some actors only got small roles, and there's lots of humours. I gave this episode 80/100. Here's my list:1>3>2