我對華納今批Abby Road Studio 歐盟制CD的一點意見

lamwaikit007

KENXYZ 發表於 2013-10-21 22:23
有無歌曲目錄相片參考呢
Thank!

別客氣。

jjjppp111

今天我終於開嚟聽，只聽了 “還有“，“此情只待成追憶“，
我可以大胆講句，係完全絕對毫無疑問地KO 呢隻abby road studio. 就算石耳、木耳都聽得出。
從前我聽舊版時，“還有“咪有D重bass 喺後面伴奏嘅，嗰D bass 咪係散散地尾兼沉唔倒嘅，聽到abby 版亦係咁，咁大家（我同家人）久而久之都以為呢首歌根本係這樣效果（專登的！），又或者想以前的錄音係咁，因為隻舊版115都係咁。  原來我錯了，我剛才聽amcd 版，眼淚都流埋，原來首歌仲可以好聽咁多同感動咁多！  未買amcd 版嘅ching 請去買番隻，我可以寫包單，你一定可以亦很樂意接受正相的威力，乜嘢bass 高音唔講，淨比清晰同音場已經去到無話可說的地步，最後多謝相位王，請受小弟一拜！

KENXYZ

早幾天我也買了王傑的AMCD



同另外其他版CD播“温柔的你”同“幾分傷心幾分痴”比較
一開聲就像一隻試音碟…音效出衆,音像聚焦力高
音場較闊較深有立體感、細緻、實淨，高低頻特別去得盡d
唯獨人聲口水聲較多,吾知呢d就係所謂Hi Fi聲

XRCD音色較厚潤
DSD三頻平均,人聲温暖
另外一隻早期Wea就低頻量明顯較少而且有硬聲




吾爭在試埋隻黑膠
又另一種聲音
真係襟聽很多
沒有CD那些毛燥感

ernietse

after reading your several format comments, tonight I compare one song 隨想曲, Paula Tsui in different format:

Regular CD 1993
20-Bit sonic solution system 1997
HQCD 2011
AMCD 2011,
SACD 2013

Regular CD, the output is medium, bass is solid, clarity is sufficient, dynamic is clear, vocal is sweet, overall warm feeling (my DENON AMP decoded playback by PCM AL-24bit)

20-Bit:, the output level is low, bass is weak, clarity not enough, no good feeling at all (my DENON AMP decoded playback by PCM AL-24bit)

AMCD: the output is loud, bass is strong, but the vocal is dull not sweet, overall flat and dull feeling (my DENON AMP decoded playback by PCM AL-24bit)

HQCD: the output is medium, bass is solid, clarity is sufficient, dynamic is good (my DENON AMP decoded playback by PCM AL-24bit)


SACD: the output medium, bass is solid, clarity is excellent, dynamic is clear, the vocal is sweet, (my DENON AMP decoded playback by DSD. not PCM AL-24bit)

My preferred choice is SACD, then Regular CD, HQCD, AMCD not impress at all, 20-Bit is the worse

So I know why those old used CD sometimes can resell so expensive

One gut feeling: new product may not always be better than the old product, it is just the excuse for the company to make more  $$$